Good Audience

what is bitcoin mining actually doing double spending

When used correctly, Bitcoin's base layer transactions on the blockchain are irreversible and final. It's no exaggeration to say that the entirety of bitcoin's system of blockchain , mining , proof of work , difficulty etc, exist to produce this history of transactions that is computationally impractical to modify.

In the literature on electronic cash, this property was often refer to as "solving the double-spending problem". Double-spending is the result of successfully spending some money more than once. Bitcoin users protect themselves from double spending fraud by waiting for confirmations when receiving payments on the blockchain, the transactions become more irreversible as the number of confirmations rises.

Other electronic systems prevent double-spending by having a master authoritative source that follows business rules for authorizing each transaction. Bitcoin uses a decentralized system, where a consensus among nodes following the same protocol and proof of work is substituted for a central authority. This means bitcoin has special properties not shared by centralized systems.

For example if you keep the private key of a bitcoin secret and the transaction has enough confirmations, then nobody can take the bitcoin from you no matter for what reason, no matter how good the excuse, no matter what. Possession of bitcoin is not enforced by business rules and policy, but cryptography and game theory.

Because bitcoin transactions can be final, merchants do not need to hassle customers for extra information like billing address, name, etc, so bitcoin can be used without registering a real name or excluding users based on age, nationality or residency. Finality in transactions means smart contracts can be created with a "code-is-law" ethos. An attempt at fraud could work that the fraudster sends a transaction paying the merchant directly to the merchant, and sends a conflicting transaction spending the coin to himself to the rest of the network.

It is likely that the second conflicting transaction will be mined into a block and accepted by bitcoin nodes as genuine. Merchants can take precautions e. The research paper Two Bitcoins at the Price of One finds that the protocol allows a high degree of success by an attacker in performing race attacks. The method studied in the research paper depends on access to the merchant's Bitcoin node which is why that even prior to this paper, recommendations for merchants include disabling incoming connections and to choose specific outgoing connections [1].

The Finney attack is a fraudulent double-spend that requires the participation of a miner once a block has been mined [2]. The risk of a Finney attack cannot be eliminated regardless of the precautions taken by the merchant, but some miner hash power is required and a specific sequence of events must occur.

A Finney attack works as follows: Suppose the attacker is generating blocks occasionally. To cheat you, when he generates a block, he doesn't broadcast it. Instead, he opens your store web page and makes a payment to your address C with his address A. You may wait a few seconds for double-spends, not hear anything, and then transfer the goods. He broadcasts his block now, and his transaction will take precedence over yours. Also referred to as a one-confirmation attack, is a combination of the race attack and the Finney attack such that a transaction that even has one confirmation can still be reversed.

The same protective action for the race attack no incoming connections, explicit outgoing connection to a well-connected node significantly reduces the risk of this occurring. It is worth noting that a successful attack costs the attacker one block - they need to 'sacrifice' a block by not broadcasting it, and instead relaying it only to the attacked node. See on BitcoinTalk or further example of an attack scenario.

This attack has a chance to work even if the merchant waits for some confirmations, but requires relatively high hashrate and risk of significant expense in wasted electricity to the attacking miner. After waiting for n confirmations, the merchant sends the product. If the attacker happened to find more than n blocks at this point, he releases his fork and regains his coins; otherwise, he can try to continue extending his fork with the hope of being able to catch up with the network. If he never manages to do this then the attack fails, the attacker has wasted a significant amount of electricity and the payment to the merchant will go through.

The probability of success is a function of the attacker's hashrate as a proportion of the total network hashrate and the number of confirmations the merchant waits for.

An online calculator can be found here. Because of the opportunity cost of this attack, it is only game-theory possible if the bitcoin amount traded is comparable to the block reward but note that an attacking miner can attempt a brute force attack against several counterparties at once. Since the attacker can generate blocks faster than the rest of the network, he can simply persevere with his private fork until it becomes longer than the branch built by the honest network, from whatever disadvantage.

No amount of confirmations can prevent this attack; however, waiting for confirmations does increase the aggregate resource cost of performing the attack, which could potentially make it unprofitable or delay it long enough for the circumstances to change or slower-acting synchronization methods to kick in.

Bitcoin's security model relies on no single coalition of miners controlling more than half the mining power. Although bitcoin's base layer blockchain transactions are irreversible, consumer protection can be implemented on a layer on top.

For example using an escrow agent is a powerful technique especially when combined with multisignature smart contracts. Also bitcoin sites such as online casinos rely on their long-standing reputation and some regulated brokers and exchanges simply rely on the legal system. Jump to: navigation , search. IO and double-spending against BetCoin Dice. Category : Technical. Navigation menu Personal tools Create account Log in.

Namespaces Page Discussion. Views Read View source View history. In other languages Deutsch. Sister projects Essays Source. This page was last edited on 12 May , at Content is available under Creative Commons Attribution 3. Privacy policy About Bitcoin Wiki Disclaimers.

what is bitcoin mining actually doing double spending

Join Bitcoin Community

Bitcoin Mining is a peer-to-peer computer process used to secure and verify bitcoin transactions—payments from one user to another on a decentralized network. Each group of transactions is called a block. Blocks are secured by Bitcoin miners and build on top of each other forming a chain. This ledger of past transactions is called the blockchain. The blockchain serves to confirm transactions to the rest of the network as having taken place. Bitcoin nodes use the blockchain to distinguish legitimate Bitcoin transactions from attempts to re-spend coins that have already been spent. Bitcoin Mining is intentionally designed to be resource-intensive and difficult so that the number of blocks found each day by miners remains steady over time, producing a controlled finite monetary supply.

Join Bitcoin Community

By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy , Privacy Policy , and our Terms of Service. As someone who uses Bitcoin, what do I need to know about how the Bitcoin system prevents double spends? Are there still circumstances where they can occur? A double spend is an attack where the given set of coins is spent in more than one transaction. There are a couple main ways to perform a double spend:. To prevent damages from the first attack - wait for one confirmation to appear on a given transaction.

what is bitcoin mining actually doing double spending

There is no such thing as a bitcoin account

Traditional currencies--like the dollar or euro--are issued by central banks. The central bank can issue new units of money ay anytime based on what they think will improve the economy. The issuance rate is set in the code, so miners cannot cheat the system or create bitcoins out of thin air.

They have to use their computing power to generate the new bitcoins. Because wwhat a when a transaction has been included in a block is it officially embedded into Bitcoin's blockchain. Distributed hash power spread among many different miners keeps Bitcoin secure and safe.

Well, you can do it. However, it's not profitable for most people as mining is a highly specialized industry. Most people should NOT mine bitcoins today. You will earn less than one penny per year and will waste money on electricity. Without a mining pool, you would only receive a mining payout if you found a block on your.

This is called solo mining. By joining a mining pool you share your hash rate with the pool. Once the pool finds a block you get a payout based on the percent of hash rate contributed to the pool.

Bitcoin mining software is bticoin you actually hook your mining hardware into your desired mining pool. Consult local counsel for further assistance in determining whether Bitcoin mining is legal and the tax implications of doing the activity.

Like other business, you can usually write off your expenses that made your operation profitable, like electricity and hardware costs. I say rough idea because many factors related to your mining profitability are constantly changing. Using an app like Crypto Miner or Easy Miner you can mine bitcoins or any other coin. Android phones simply are not powerful enough to match the mining doubble used by serious operations. So, it might be cool to setup a miner on your Android phone to see how it works.

Enterprising coders soon discovered they could get more hashing power from graphic cards and wrote mining software to allow. Nowadays all serious Bitcoin mining is performed on ASICs, usually in thermally-regulated data-centers with access to low-cost electricity.

Economies of scale have thus led to the what is bitcoin mining actually doing double spending of mining power into fewer hands than originally intended. Pools are groups of cooperating miners who agree to share block rewards in proportion to their contributed mining power. This pie chart displays the current distribution of total mining power by pools:.

As Bitcoin could easily replace PayPal, credit card companies, banks and the bureaucrats who regulate them all, it begs the question:. If only 21 million Bitcoins will ever be created, why has the issuance of Bitcoin not accelerated with the rising power of mining hardware?

Issuance is regulated by Difficulty, an algorithm which adjusts the difficulty of the Proof of Work problem in accordance with how quickly blocks are solved within a certain timeframe roughly every 2 weeks or blocks. Difficulty rises and acutally with deployed hashing power to keep the average time between blocks at around 10 minutes.

Satoshi designed Bitcoin such that the block reward, which miners automatically ix for solving a block, is halved everyblocks or roughly 4 years. To successfully attack the Bitcoin network by creating blocks with a falsified transaction record, a dishonest nitcoin would require the majority of mining power so as to maintain the longest chain. Pools and specialized hardware has unfortunately led to a centralization trend in Bitcoin mining. Bitcoin mining is certainly not perfect but possible improvements are always being suggested and considered.

Green sends 1 bitcoin to Red. A full node is a special, transaction-relaying wallet which maintains a current copy of the entire blockchain. If there are no conflicts e. At this point, the transaction has not yet entered the Blockchain. Red would be taking a big risk by doble any goods to Green before the transaction is confirmed. So how do transactions get confirmed? This is where Miners enter the picture.

Miners, like full nodes, maintain a complete copy of the blockchain and monitor the network for newly-announced transactions. In either case, a miner then performs work in an attempt to fit all new, valid transactions into the current block. Acceptable blocks include a solution to a Proof of Work computational problem, known as a hash. The more computing power a miner controls, the higher their hashrate and the greater their odds of solving the current block.

But why do miners invest in expensive computing hardware and race dokng other to solve blocks? And what is a hash? If you pasted correctly — as a string hash with no spaces after the exclamation mark — the SHA algorithm used in Bitcoin should produce:. So, a hash is a way to verify any amount of data is accurate. To solve a block, miners modify non-transaction data in the current block such that their hash result begins with a certain number according to the current Difficultycovered below of zeroes.

If other full nodes agree the block is valid, the new block is added to the blockchain and the entire process begins afresh. Red may now consider sending the goods to Green. You may have heard hitcoin Bitcoin transactions are irreversible, so why is it advised acutally await several confirmations?

The answer is somewhat complex and requires a solid understanding of the above mining process:. There are now two competing versions of the blockchain! Which blockchain prevails? Quite simply, the longest valid chain becomes the official version of events.

A loses his mining reward and fees, which only exist on the invalidated A -chain. The more confirmations have passed, the safer a transaction is considered. In MarchMotherboard projected this:. On an industrial level, Bitcoin may be considered a system which converts electricity directly into money. Given that electricity is, at present, primarily generated through unsustainable methods, eco-activists hold that all energy expenditures must be critically weighed against their debatable contribution to climate change.

This group is best exemplified by Paul Krugman, who argues that Bitcoin and to a lesser extent, gold has no real value to society and so represents a waste of resources and labour. After all, social pressure to sustainably power the Bitcoin project is sensible. We need to maintain a healthy balance between nature and technology. Over the millennia, history has repeatedly shown that prosperity depends on sound money. Whether it was the Roman Empire debasing its coinage or modern central banks inflating roing supply of fiat money….

The end result of currency debasement is, tragically and invariably, economic crisis. Simply put, currency with no backing but faith in its controllers tends to be short-lived foing ruinous in its hyper-inflationary death throes.

Bitcoin was designed with one monetary goal foremost in mind: avoiding the dismal fate of previous monetary forms by preventing the evils of debasement.

Bitcoiners are some of the lucky few not regularly revising their economic expectations downwards. The major determinants of profitability in the fiercely competitive world of Bitcoin mining are low electricity costs, access to cutting-edge ASIC mining acyually and deep knowledge of Bitcoin and business.

Miners in any cool region, which is connected to cheap geothermal or hydro-electric power, have a similar advantage. This short documentary explores the inner workings of a Chinese mining operation.

Mining is a growing industry which provides employment, not only for those who run the machines but those who build. Given the sluggish global economy, new and promising industries should be celebrated!

Such debasement punishes savers in particular, as the value of their stored wealth is eroded. Savers naturally spendjng to protect their fiat savings by translating them to a more durable form, such as foreign currency or investments. China is known for its particularly strict limitations. Investing in a mining operation brings a steady stream of bitcoins; a form of what is bitcoin mining actually doing double spending largely beyond the control of the ruling class.

For those laboring under restrictive capital controls, mining therefore represents an excellent if unconventional solution. Given the relative costs and risks of other wealth-preservation measures, it dling even be worthwhile to mine Bitcoin at a loss!

A lot of that money flowed into real estate purchases in Western cities such as Vancouver. This phenomenon has created localized bubbles and unaffordable housing conditions for residents. The likely outcome is a disastrous crash which sets the regional economy back by years. By contrast, Bitcoin mining represents an effective means to preserve wealth without creating such undesirable and risky market distortions.

Besides raw electricity, there are many other resources necessary to the minjng operation of the fiat system but not to Bitcoin. For example:. In any fair and comprehensive comparison of resource costs between the two systems, Bitcoin is likely to compare very favorably!

As mentioned under Reason 2mining in a cool climate is advantageous as the mining process generates a great deal of waste heat. However, enterprising Bitcoin miners can capture and use this heat productively! There are many examples of data centres re-using heat for example, IBM Switzerland warming a public swimming pool which Bitcoin miners could follow.

As for office or home use, an additional source of passive Bitcoin income may serve to make cozy indoor temperatures a spendingg affordable proposition. Although gas, wood, oil and propane remain the cheaper heating options, electricity does tend to be the most convenient. The good news is that, according to the somewhat out-dated calculations of a New York-based miner, mining rigs offer considerable cost savings over standard electric heaters.

As an additional benefit, mining rigs may be precisely controlled via common computing hardware, such that a customized heating schedule or adaptive climate control system may be programmed with relative ease. The only downside for home miners is that mining rigs are often noisy and un-anaesthetically-pleasing devices.

As a result, they tend to be sequestered in the basement or garage for the sake of domestic harmony. Various companies are combining Bitcoin mining and heating into smart devices, to the benefit of both industries.

What is Bitcoin Mining?

What if the two transactions double spending are picked from the pool to be included in the same block. Well, not really. But Bitcoin is digital money, not physical cash. Finality in transactions means smart contracts can be created with a "code-is-law" ethos. Due to the "avalanche effect," however, even a tiny change to any portion of the original data will result in a totally unrecognizable hash. Login Newsletters. See responses When a miner finds a solution, it is supposed to be broadcasted to all other miners so that they can verify it whereafter the block is added to the blockchain the miners reach consensus. Blockchain Terminology: Basic terminology to get you started. Whichever transaction gets verified first and gets 6 confirmations will bitclin accepted, and the other will be discarded. You may wait a few seconds for double-spends, not hear anything, and then transfer what is bitcoin mining actually doing double spending goods. Primecoin Verge Vertcoin Zcoin. They told me to wait but I am very worry because it is a lot of money. I mean, we are talking about 0. Content is available under Creative Commons Attribution 3. If this user controls the blockchain they will be able to process transfer bitcoins to bitfoin wallet multiple times by reversing the blockchain ledger as though the initial transactions had never occurred.

PREV: whats up with bitcoin cash

NEXT: what does warren buffet say about bitcoin